Skip to content

What do we carry ?

Salima Hakim, Her Cabinet of Curiosities (detail), 2024

Publié le 14/05/2025

Entitled to carry, the Sharjah Biennial offers a poetic journey across the emirate. Led by a quintet of curators from different parts of the world, this edition celebrates transgenerational and cross-border solidarity throughout the Global South. Artists weave bridges between ancestral knowledge, intimate narratives, and collective struggles. As we explore the exhibitions, their works invite us to embrace vulnerability and turn transmission into an act of resistance. From Sharjah, Marziah Rashid offers us some ideas for navigating this biennial and grasping its rich polyphony.

In a darkened, hushed gallery, I hear the familiar strains of soz khwani filling the space like a physical entity. This form of elegiac poetry, rendered in song, is traditionally recited by Shia Muslims from the Indian subcontinent – including my own family – in commemoration of the martyrs of the battle of Karbala, a crucial turning point in the history of Islam. Heralded by the sounds of lamentation, Fazal Rizvi’s commission for Sharjah Biennial 16 slowly materialises before eyes adjusting to the darkness. A mound of earth like a fresh grave rests on the floor, unpretentious, yet visceral. Beyond two calligraphy works that bear witness to the tragic events of Karbala, echoing the mournful verses that envelop the scene, is a white stone platform surrounded by plastic buckets. I recognise it instantly as a table on which the ghusl (washing of the body) is carried out before the dead are laid to rest.

Entitled Kissing of the threshold, the work links individual and collective expressions of grief – calling to mind another exhibition, the artist’s solo show at Grey Noise Gallery in 2019, which also grappled with death and remembrance. How do we remember? featured an installation recreating the bedroom of his late grandmother, accompanied by a book on Shia practices of commemoration which, Murtaza Vali writes, “suggests that, regardless of belief, the ways you are taught to mourn en masse invariably shape how you privately process grief and remember your dead.” Both works gesture to that which we carry with us, that which has been carried across generations of time, and the moments when they coincide. As a casual follower, at best, of the faith I was born into, encountering Kissing of the threshold brought something to the surface.

An ode to vulnerability

The title of Sharjah Biennial 16 is to carry, a word that connects past with present, here with there, and self with other, expanding on the biennial’s founding curatorial model of recovering and recentring systems of thought arising from the Global South. As the poem that opens the curatorial statement demonstrates, it is also a verb that is generous and abundant, a wellspring of different grammatical objects that range from the tangible to the conceptual. This open-endedness invites vulnerability, asking the viewer to consider – as I was moved to, confronted by Rizvi’s work – what it is that they carry with and within them. A biennial theme that calls on the viewer to relate to it, in a field that so often insists on maintaining a front of academic detachment, is rather satisfying. The five curators themselves carry out their work from a place of vulnerability, each situating their project in a personal narrative that nonetheless has implications beyond the personal.

At the same time, the individual inquiries of Alia Swastika, Amal Khalaf, Megan Tamati-Quennell, Natasha Ginwala and Zeynep Öz coalesce into a single question: How can we mobilise ancestral knowledge, memories and histories that we carry to make sense of the world? While Swastika draws our attention to knowledge produced and preserved by women, Khalaf proposes that this effort can offer a framework for resisting political, social and environmental injustices. Ginwala considers how water bodies and song connect us across time and generations, and Tamati-Quennell explores the First Nations relationship with the land as well as solidarities across geographies. Öz’s curation, finally, centres around YAZ Publications, a book series that examines the economic and relational impact of past, present and future technological change.

In the works selected for the biennial, ancestral knowledge takes various forms, from stories and myths to rituals and song. Kissing of the threshold asks what we can learn about solidarity and collective action through the historical retelling of the story of Karbala, which is, at its core, one of truth to power. Risham Syed’s Unn, Pani, Sut (Grain, Water, Truth) (2024) evokes the dependence of sustenance on community through its reference to the Sikh tradition of langar, or the practice of distributing free meals. The multimedia installation weaves through a repurposed house in Mureijah Square, taking the viewer from wheat patches planted by the artist to a kinetic sculpture that evokes a shishi-odoshi, against the backdrop of poetic verses by Guru Nanak set to music. 

Bulgwang-dong Totem (2010) is a series of photographic prints by Sangdon Kim, whose work comments on how we inevitably turn to spiritual culture during times of civilizational crisis. Drawing on Korean shamanic practices, the works depict plastic chairs adorned with plants and flowers, strings of garlic and onions, shells and other organic materials. The objects seem to climb the chairs like a menacing overgrowth to form totems. One photograph features the distinctive Monobloc, a modern-day symbol of mass production and consumption at great environmental costs. In a similar vein, John Clang’s Reading by an Artist (2023 – ongoing), consisting of photographs, testimonies and a performance, speaks to the popularity of divination practices such as astrology and tarot, reading as a result of widespread disillusionment with supposedly rational modern institutions. Clang reads fortunes for individual sitters using a form of geomancy based on zi wei dou shu, an ancient Chinese metaphysical philosophy.

Passing on ancestral knowledge

Citra Sasmita’s Timur Merah Project XV: Poetry of The Sea, Vow of The Sun (2024) is among a plethora of works across the biennial that highlight that the genealogy of ancestral knowledge can often be traced back to women. The work contemplates the life of Ida I Dewa Agung Istri Kanya, the Queen of Klungkung, Bali, who has been marginalised in Indonesia’s historical record, despite leading efforts to compile an archive of oral histories pertaining to indigenous knowledge. It consists of three cage-like tapestries embroidered with Balinese literary symbols – a winged deer, a two-headed falcon, an ouroboros – with video works ensconced inside. The Queen is also the subject of the paintings by Mangku Muriati that surround the sculpture. Exploiting the Kamasan shadow-puppet style, traditionally used to portray classical narratives in visual form, to reinterpret manuscripts with a gendered lens, the artist herself participates in the conservation of knowledge that is sidelined in the archives. Thanks to Swastika’s curatorial contribution, many of the works on display reflect on weaving and textiles as carriers of women’s knowledge, including Sasmita’s installation. Even if the medium is, at times, too heavily relied upon, some works raise critical questions about the very category of ‘women’s knowledge’. Salima Hakim’s Her Cabinet of Curiosities (2024) comprises a collection of hand-stitched replicas of archaeological artefacts and texts surrounding the 2003 excavation of a female skeleton of Homo floresiensis, an early human species, in Flores, Indonesia. By rendering the tools of scientific research in the language of a traditionally female craft, Hakim destabilises the hierarchical relationship between them.

Other works consider the forces that inhibit, rather than enable, the transfer of ancestral knowledge across time, positing or embodying strategies for its reclamation. Rully Shabara presents a museum display about the so-called Wusa people, which turns out to be entirely fictional. Yet it is utterly, unsettlingly convincing at first glance, causing us to question the trust we place in the language of museology. The Photo Kegham of Gaza: Unboxing series depicts slices of life in the city and portraits of townspeople prior to its siege in 1948, captured by the founder of its first photography studio, Kegham Djeghalian Sr. While at risk of romanticising Gaza’s past, considering Jewish settlements in the city predated the Nakba, the work makes a strong case for the importance of subjective histories: memories carried across time, in the form of photographs, make the erasure of Palestinian identity impossible. 

Raven Chacon’s sound work A Wandering Breeze (2025) echoes through the abandoned sand-filled houses of Al Madam Buried Village, located in the desert between Sharjah and Oman. Built in the 1970s as a public housing project for a local Bedouin tribe, to introduce sedentism during a time of rapid modernisation, the buildings were deserted two decades later when frequent sandstorms made living conditions intractable. Developed in collaboration with Zinat Sharjah, a traditional Emirati folk band, the work is like a ghostly lament reasserting a nomadic way of life, while signaling the absurdity of the project.   

Back in the city of Sharjah, Chacon’s photographs of Mariano Lake and Chilchinbeto in the Navajo Nation, the sites of similar government housing developments, draw parallels between the struggles of both communities. Further extending this call for cross-border solidarity, these works are juxtaposed with Mara TK’s From the River to the Sea (2025), in collaboration with Rana Hamida and Reem Sawan. A Māori translation of the Palestinian political slogan, the work evokes the relationship with the land, vital to both cultures: “Before the cascading here and now of these colonial projects—WE KNOW RIVERS,” the artist is quoted as saying in an accompanying text. “We are the rivers and we are the sea.” 

Like Chacon’s sound work, Raafat Majzoub’s multimedia installation is site-responsive, composed of repurposed elements from 1970s buildings currently under renovation in Sharjah. Based on an earlier sculpture created with materials sourced from garbage-strewn areas of Lebanon, the work plays with perspective by bringing the crisis to a far more economically stable context. It is one of several collaborative works in the biennial, including Womanifesto’s WeMend (2023 – ongoing) project, which engages communities of women from across the world to stitch a patchwork canopy in Calligraphy Square. That many of these works respond to more than one curatorial line of inquiry is a testament to the shared knowledge, afflictions and practices of different cultures that the biennial seeks to mobilise to foster solidarity.

On the importance of heeding stories

Writing this essay during the Islamic month of Shabaan, I am reminded of another story I heard growing up, traditionally recited by women at gatherings around food during this holy period. It tells of a poor woodcutter and his wife who are blessed by good fortune after heeding Imam Ja’far al-Sadiq, a venerated figure in Twelver Shi’ism, who visits the wife in a dream and instructs her to make an offering in his name during times of hardship. The woman relays the story to her employer, the prime minister’s wife, who is at first skeptical of its truth. Soon after, the prime minister and his wife meet with a terrible misfortune when they are falsely accused of a crime, exiled and imprisoned by the king. In desperation, they turn to the Imam’s instructions and are mercifully absolved. 

This story is didactic on the surface, intended to instruct the listener about the Imam’s benevolence and the power of appealing to him. But if it were as simple as that, it might have ended with the blessings that befall the woodcutter and his wife. It is in the second chapter, when the theory is put to the test by the other couple, where its wisdom lies: it is a story, finally, about the importance of heeding stories.

Marziah Rashid